This paper studies the overview of investment property accounting and the presentation of the fair
value of investment property in Vietnamese enterprises. The research sample covers 68
enterprises engaged in investment property business in Hanoi. The research results show that
83.8% of enterprises do not present the fair value of investment property on their financial
statements at the end of the accounting year. In addition, the results of the research also show
necessary reasons to apply fair value accounting to the investment property. Based on the results
of the research, the paper proposes some recommendations for the State agencies and enterprises
to move forward with the usage of fair value accounting for investment property in Vietnamese
enterprises.
10 trang |
Chia sẻ: Thục Anh | Ngày: 24/05/2022 | Lượt xem: 430 | Lượt tải: 0
Nội dung tài liệu The study of fair value accounting for investment property in Vietnamese enterprises, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
l estate market in particular. The core
issue of using fair value accounting is to have adequate economic conditions. If the
socioeconomic conditions are not adequate, the use of fair value may be misused or
misleading financial information. On the other hand, it is always urgent to provide useful
63
accounting information to the users. Therefore, short term and long-term solutions are
needed. In the short term, when Vietnamese accountants do not have enough socio-economic
conditions to apply fair value right away to investment property, it is necessary to minimize
the disadvantages of the historical cost model in current investment property accounting.
The authors suggest that accounting should be taken to recognize the impairment of
investment property in enterprises in the coming time and from then forward to use the fair
value model for investment property in future.
Secondly: Complete the legal system on property valuation
Establishing the legal framework, regulations and procedures for property valuation
is an important aspect of state management of property market. Developed countries have
focused on building property valuation systems to operate and control property transactions
and tax collection. From that point of view, it is necessary to step by step complete a
functioning market system and continue to issue Vietnam's valuation standards. Currently
Vietnam has 12 price evaluation standards. The system of price valuation standards in
Vietnam has been developed in a relatively complete manner and is in line with
international valuation standards, including ethical rules, value bases and price appraisal
process, price appraisal method, valuation of some properties such as real estate, intangible
assets. Current standards still can not meet the "fair value" determination in the investment
property accounting. On the other hand, the application of these methods in accounting in
general and in investment property accounting in particular is still not specified, so it should
be promulgated in the future.
Thirdly: Capacity building for accountants, users of financial reports and
management agencies
It can be said that fair value accounting is relatively complex and confusing for
users, even in developed economies. At present, accounting staff in most enterprises have not
had access to this concept. Determining fair value is usually accompanied by estimates,
assumptions in the future. In order to minimize the risk of manipulation of data for personal
purposes, the legal corridor, the capacity of the price appraisal team, the management agencies,
the tax office, the auditing unit, the users of financial statements must be substantially
improved in order to access and prevent potential frauds. In addition, the training and
development of qualified human resources on IFRS should be emphasized.
6. Conclusions, limitations and research sequences
6.1 Conclusions
Real estate business is one of the most important markets of the market economy,
directly related to a tremendous amount of property in terms of scale, nature and value. In
particular, the operation of investment property business has a lot of characteristics, which
require a lot of capital and a long time investment, is regarded as risky business activities.
This requires these enterprises in this area to be in control of their operations through the
use of multiple management tools, and accounting is considered one of the most effective
management tools to provide useful information for the control and decision making of
64
corporate executives. With the need to provide useful information, enterprises will be more
and more aware of the important role of using fair value in accounting in general and in
investment property in particular. Based on the results of the study, the article proposes
some recommendations for state agencies and enterprises to move forward the route of
using the fair value model for investment property in Vietnamese enterprises.
6.2 Limitations and research sequences
The sample size of the study is just limited to enterprises in Hanoi, other studies
may expand the sample size in enterprises in the whole country.
The paper is implemented in the context of accounting standards system, the
circulars of investment property accounting guidelines of Vietnam has been issued but
many contents have not converged with the international general regulations. However,
when Vietnam issues new and revised accounting standards in integration with IFRS, new
research projects may be implemented such as: Study the factors that lead to the decision
to apply the fair value model or the historical cost model to the investment property in
businesses; Study on the usefulness of the information presented in the financial reports
on the investment property after Vietnam issued the standard accounting system in the
integration with IFRS.
7. References
Mai Ngoc Anh, Luu Duc Tuyen, Nguyen Vu Viet (2014), Some topics on accounting
theory, Finance Publishing House, 2014.
The Ministry of Finance (2013), Vietnam Accounting Standards System, Finance
Publishing House, Hanoi.
The Ministry of Finance (2014), Circular 200/2014/ TT-BTC guiding the enterprise
accounting regime, issued on December 22, 2014.
Ministry of Finance, Association of Accountants, Auditors, ACCA (2016), IFRS,
Opportunities and Challenges for Integration in Vietnam, Conference proceedings, Finance
Publishing House, December 2016.
Chen Chen, Kin Lo, Desmon Tsang and Jing Zhang (2013), Earnings management,
firm location, and financial reporting choice: An analysis of fair value reporting for
investment properties in emerging market, Contemporary Accounting Research, Singgapore
Management University
Dang Ngoc Hung (2016), "Study of factors affecting the application of accounting
standards in Vietnam", Journal of Economics and Development, No. 225 March 2016.
Fadia Burhan Alhaj Ahmad1 & Mohammad Suleiman Aladwan2 (2015), “The Effect of
Fair Value Accounting on Jordanian Investment Properties An Empirical Study on Jordanian
Listed Real Estate Companies”, International Journal of Financial Research Vol. 6, No. 4; 2015
International Accounting Standards Boad (2010), The Conceptual Framework for
Financial Reporting, was approved by the IASB, September, 2010.
65
International Accounting Standards Boad (2012), IFRS 13 - Fair Value Measurement.
Liapis, K. J and Christodoulopoulou, E. P (2011): “How GAAP and accounting
treatments influence property management”, Journal of Property Investment & Finance,Vol.
29 Issue: Number 3, p251-279.
Nguyen The Loc (2010), Applying international accounting standards, specialized
issues on financial reporting, Orient Publishing House, Ho Chi Minh.
Nicole Promper (2010) “Fair value accounting in the real estate industry - An
empirical investigation of the decision usefulness of accounting figures based on IFRS and
US GAAP”, Working paper, Department of Accounting and Auditing Johannes Kepler
University Linz, Austria.
Pham, HH (2012), A comparative study of Vietnamese and international accounting
standards, PhD, Curtin University.
Pham Thi Minh Hong and Tran Manh Dung (2013), "Historical cost model and fair
value model for tangible fixed asset accounting", Journal of Economics and Development,
Special Issue 10/2013.
Tran Quang Chung and Vu Thi Lan Huong (2013), "Discussing the Application of
International Financial Reporting Standard 13 in Fair Value Measuring of Equity
Instruments in the Stock Market "Journal of Economics and Development, 10/2013.
Sati P. Bandyopadhyaya, Changling Chena, Mindy Wolfeb (2017), “The predictive
ability of investment property fair value adjustments under IFRS and the role of accounting
conservatism”, Journal of Advances in Accounting 05.2017.
National Assembly of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam (2014), Law No. 66/2014/QH13
of the National Assembly: Law on real estate business, issued on 25/11/2014.
National Assembly of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam (2015), Law No.
88/2015/QH13 of the National Assembly: Law on Accounting, issued on 20/11/2015.
Vu Manh Chien and Le Nhu Tuyen (2014), "International Accounting Standards and
International Financial Reporting Standards for Construction Experience for Vietnam",
Journal of Commerce, December 2013, January 2014
Vu Dinh Hien (2015), "Fair value - the basis of value measurement in financial
reporting", Journal of Economics and Development, December 2015.
Vu Huu Duc (2010), The Fundamentals of Accounting Theory, Labor Publishing
House 2010.
Worldbank (2016), Assessment reporting of compliance on the standards and
regulations of accounting & auditing, Hong Duc Publishing.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- the_study_of_fair_value_accounting_for_investment_property_i.pdf